Regional Sessions: This was our final day in regional sessions. We got together and finished up our packets on how to spread our stories to others. This included (at least for my group) making a mock organization using one of the case studies. We then decided what type of roles we would like to have in this organization and what we would do in these roles.
| Here are some photos to break up all the words This is China Town |
Ohio Session: After we were done with regional group sessions we got into our separate state sessions, for all the other states this was a bit more of a thing since they had been in larger groups prior to this. For us however it was the same group just a different room. We got excited, cheered for our schools, made up ohio chants and were just loud. Then we attempted to take a photo together which took a bit of effort.
| Bomb Pop from the Ice Cream Truck!! |
Non-violence Direct Action Training: In the afternoon I went to the NVDA seminar, which is what i was most excited for the whole weekend. The session was being taught by Greenpeace employees and looked intriguing. I have had a passion for non-violence ever since I took a class on Gandhi and Non-violence sophomore year, so I had high expectations.
It wasn't what I expected.
It was an active seminar which was good. We pushed all the chairs to the side and they would discuss a subject and then we would do a little activity or the other way around. We got in lines and had to do some roleplaying of non-violent action situations. We became a living graph that represented when we thought actions were violent vs non-violent and effective vs non effective, in order to show that everyone's views are different. We also got into groups and came up with what we thought the steps toward organizing a non-violent group action are.
| Outside the National Archives |
This is wear the disenchantment really set in. Before this there were a few situations where I was uncomfortable with what they were saying about what was violent and what wasn't. About what was action and what wasn't. I was open to be proven wrong though, I was in the session to learn. When we started to discuss the steps towards organizing your action I suggested that you must make your plan known, to the police and to the people you are protesting against.
This idea stems from my study of Gandhi, he believed that to be truly non-violent you must be totally open about what you are doing. Which means doing things like writing letters to the people you are protesting about and informing the police. That way they had the opportunity to decided to discuss with you rather than have you protest if the wanted to and it also made it clear that you were not trying to sneak around. In my view it shows that you fully support your endeavors and are willing to announce them even if it means everyone will try to stop you.
This also ties into Gandhi's belief that a person should not do things with the result in mind, but only with the action in mind. Though that is a totally different discussion.
| A create-your-own frozen yogurt shop |
The response I got from our group leader however, was that it is not necessary to let people know what you are doing, and at times it is best not to let them know. I was taken aback. Perhaps it is because my study of NVDA is mostly theoretical and based largely with Gandhi as my example along with others who followed his teachings. I sincerely believe that being open about what you are doing is the only way to stay non-violent.
From that point on I was a bit more critical of the Greenpeace method of NVDA. To me it seemed rather violent. Not in the sense that they physically hurt people, but that they inflicted other violence on people. Emotional, mental, spiritual. Destroying a person's property is violent to me. Deliberately breaking the law when that is not the actual action is violent to me.
To explain this I will use two examples. The first is: A new law is put into place that says you must paint your house green if you make more than $100,000 a year. You think that is breaks your constitutional rights and are against it. So you don't paint your house even though you make $200,000 a year, you have just broken the law.
The second example is that you believe that painting houses green for this reason discriminates against those who do not make that much money, so in protest you go to every green house and paint a big red "X" on it. You have broken the law by breaking and entering and destroying property.
To me the first example is non-violent and the second is not. In the first example the law breaking is the action. In the second it is just a means to the action (protesting).
So overall the NVDA was interesting and thought invoking, but left me with a weird taste in my mouth.
Powershift was a great experience overall, I learned a lot
